Anthropic updates Claude’s rule on copying games
Photo source: Tom’s Hardware
Claude will offer to create an original game in the same genre instead of copying an existing game. This change follows complaints that the old rule blocked legitimate projects.
As more people began using AI tools to copy games and study how they work, Anthropic blocked its tools from doing these tasks. However, game developers complained that this rule also stopped them from using Claude for legitimate projects. Anthropic has now changed the rule, according to a post on X by Addy Osmani, a member of its technical staff.
This was reported by Tom’s Hardware.
Last week, some of you found that Claude Code refused to work on game projects it should have been able to build. We had added a short rule to the Opus 5.5 prompt to stop Claude from recreating specific existing games. But the rule also caused problems when you mentioned a game only to explain the game mechanics you wanted.
– Addy Osmani
We changed this rule in version 2.1.317. You can now name a game to explain what you want, and Claude should create an original game in the same genre. If you ask it to copy the original game, it will offer to make something similar instead.
– Addy Osmani
In the past, taking apart a game's code to understand how it worked was difficult. Teams of skilled volunteers could spend months or even years doing it. AI tools have made this work faster and easier, although they do not always produce clean results.
Some people have used this technology to study game demos made by small and independent developers. They then threaten to release AI-completed versions of those games unless the developers pay them a ransom. This puts the developers' work at risk. The attackers demand money to stop the games from being exposed or ruined.
Anthropic's engineers are trying to find a balance. They want to stop people from using its tools to copy games while still allowing paying customers to use Claude to create their own games. They also want to avoid upsetting major software companies, publishers and game developers.
We want Claude to be as helpful as possible when you’re creating something original. But we also want to protect your work if someone else tries to copy it.
– Addy Osmani
The source also points out that powerful new AI systems can help programmers and developers work faster and more efficiently. However, they can also make it easier to create basic copies of expensive software, such as Adobe Creative Suite and Microsoft Office.
