Op-Ed: Anthropic stock will test market faith in AI, maybe right down to the bone

There is a limit to how much excitement and hype the stock market will accept. SpaceX showed this recently. Anthropic is very different, but it is a company that represents the most advanced AI technology.
That image is being seriously challenged every second. Trust in AI is a huge problem that cannot be avoided. There are also many concerns about risk. Investing in this company means entering unknown territory, and traditional investors may be very cautious.
The move from private ownership to public ownership is almost unique. Anthropic's major technology partners and other business partners are taking part in the IPO. They are also reported to have agreed to buy more shares.
The IPO so far
The latest information about Anthropic's planned NASDAQ stock offering is fairly simple. The shares are expected to start at a price between $70 and $78 each, with 825 million shares being offered.
The company is building a solid base of income. Its revenue is respectable, even if it is not amazing. It is growing at a steady pace rather than very quickly.
Anthropic also has some a large amount of debt and other financial responsibilities. Together, these add up to $895 billion, according to the most precise figure that appears to be publicly available.
Strangely, nobody seems very worried about this huge number. The debts and other financial responsibilities are clearly listed. They are not unexpected surprises.
The fact that Anthropic has enough credibility for such a large number to be discussed says something about the company. Usually, this much debt would cause widespread panic among investors in traditional public companies.
The AI future minefield
Investors will begin testing their trust in Anthropic and AI as soon as the company goes public. From the day its shares are listed, Anthropic will face a huge list of possible future problems. Any of them could become serious. One less obvious problem is how to fit today's AI technology into the world's huge collection of old software, hardware, and ways of thinking.
For example, reports about problems in old software are nothing new. These problems were widely discussed 20 years ago, and not much has changed since then. They are built into the digital systems that people and businesses depend on. In many cases, they have become a normal part of how these systems work.
For AI to grow, Anthropic and other AI companies will have to replace these old systems almost completely. They will also need to convince markets to accept the new systems and sell them to businesses, financial companies, and governments that may not trust them. Until that happens, these old systems will continue to make progress difficult. This is a huge challenge that cannot be avoided. How can investors put money into something that basically means rebuilding the world's entire digital infrastructure from the ground up at the lowest levels? Can you see how this might affect the stock price?
The problem with being the public face of American AI
Being well known can sometimes be a problem. Anthropic's high public profile has brought both benefits and difficulties. The company has had several dealings with the current US administration, and not all of these dealings have been positive.
Another important point is that Anthropic, along with its leading product, Claude and the mysterious Mythos, receives a great deal of attention in almost every news story about AI. This could create problems for the company as a publicly traded business. Claude has achieved a good level of use and acceptance in the market by almost any measure. This is because businesses are adopting it to meet real needs. However, this unusual success also brings higher expectations. Customers will expect more and demand higher standards.
The stock market is not especially good at understanding complicated subjects. It understands stock prices, but not much else. Most other things are beyond its understanding. When a company is this well known, investors may react to almost anything that happens.
Being an American company is also no longer the automatic advantage it once was. For now, it has effectively become a disadvantage. This may change, but at present it is a major problem that nobody wants to deal with.
For some reason, doing business with the United States is not as straightforward as it used to be. Could global trade problems affect Anthropic? Certainly. This may be especially true in the European Union and in countries with rules that can be legally enforced.
Even when Anthropic does everything extremely well, legal and regulatory requirements can still affect how investors see the company. These issues often have a direct effect on profits and costs. There is a fine line between sensible checking and unnecessary criticism. But AI affects every kind of business, so almost any issue could suddenly become a serious problem.
Worldwide AI rules have not yet been fully established. New regulations could increase costs, and a court case anywhere in the world could create financial or legal responsibilities. Anthropic may be a likely target simply because of its high profile. Fairness and stock market values do not always go together.
Now try to work out in a tiny fraction of a second how the stock market will react. Sounds like fun, doesn't it?
Competition matters, a lot, and it will matter a lot more soon enough
Anthropic and the other major AI companies are at an important turning point in history. Their biggest competition right now comes from China, with its organized business models and ability to produce things on a large scale. Other competitors will appear soon as AI becomes more common and the market for physical AI products grows. Working together on new AI technology outside the United States could quickly change the AI market.
For everyday consumers, it is easy to see that new markets will eventually include AI tools that people can build or customize themselves, AI products made for specific brands, and cheap AI products sold using marketing methods like those used by Temu. The high cost of developing and running AI cannot be assumed to stay the same. Subscription services are already showing signs of reaching a limit in their growth. Hardware costs could also become a major problem, even for basic products. We could easily see a competition between Microsoft and Apple in smartphones alone, before even considering new operating systems.
Anthropic deserves some credit for simply making it this far while facing all these challenges. The future will be crowded with competitors and problems, but it will also be interesting.
