Nvidia scandal exposes limits of America's AI strategy

Daily Sabah

Source published: Site published:

Original article · فارسی

The latest scandal involving Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang is about much more than the personal life of a technology leader. It has revealed problems with America's plan to control China's access to advanced artificial intelligence technology. Washington is trying many ways to stop Beijing from getting powerful computer chips, but the global technology industry is making this goal harder to achieve.

Nvidia's longtime CEO, Jensen Huang, was forced to step down on Nov. 12 after information about his relationships became public. These included a relationship with Alice Huang, a former executive at Megaspeed International, a technology company based in Singapore. U.S. officials said Alice Huang had links to Chinese intelligence. Her former employer, Megaspeed, also came under investigation over possible violations of American rules on chip exports.

However, none of these American claims has been proven. Singapore has said there is no evidence that Alice Huang was a Chinese spy. U.S. intelligence agencies have also not shared enough evidence to show that she was working for China in any way. Megaspeed has also denied doing anything wrong and says it has started an investigation following outside pressure.

These details are very important. Serious claims about national security problems must be supported by evidence, not rumours. But the scandal also raises a much bigger question: If the United States cannot properly track how its most valuable technology is used, how can it expect to stay ahead of China?

For about four years, Washington has been making its rules on selling advanced computer chips to China stricter. The main goal is to stop Beijing from getting the computing power it needs to grow its AI industry and related military abilities.

Nvidia, an American company, plays a central role in this effort because its chips are widely used to build and run advanced AI systems. The company has gained greatly from the worldwide AI boom and reached a market value of more than $4 trillion last year.

But stopping direct sales does not always stop people from getting access to advanced technology.

Companies in other countries can buy advanced chips where sales are allowed. They can then rent out the computing power to customers in other parts of the world, including China. This means Chinese businesses can use Nvidia chips in data centers overseas without having to bring the physical chips into China.

This is probably one of the biggest weaknesses in Washington's current plan. U.S. rules focus mainly on where chips are sold and shipped. But the growing cloud computing industry allows people to use the power of these chips from far away.

The numbers are also worrying. Nvidia's revenue from Singapore rose to $23.7 billion in 2024, up from $2.3 billion in 2022. Singapore's parliament reported that the country made up 22% of Nvidia's recent revenue, even though only about 1% of the company's total revenue came from chips physically shipped there.

These numbers do not prove that chips were illegally moved or smuggled. However, they show why governments are worried about the difference between where technology is sold and where it is finally used.

The latest scandal also raises questions about the responsibilities of major technology companies.

Nvidia works in a global market and has strong business reasons to keep access to China. Jensen Huang has said many times that American companies should be allowed to compete in the Chinese market instead of giving that market to local competitors.

There is a reasonable point behind this argument. Completely cutting China off from American companies could push it to develop its own alternatives much faster. It could also reduce the worldwide influence of American technology companies.

But business interests cannot always come before national security. A company selling billions of dollars' worth of advanced technology must know who its final customers are and where its products are really going.

Nvidia says it ended its business relationship with Megaspeed in June last year and stopped taking new orders from the Singapore-based company. This raises another question: What warning signs did Nvidia notice, and did it notice them early enough?

The investigation should find out what Nvidia knew and whether its checks and safety measures were strong enough. It would be unfair to assume that the company knowingly helped anyone break the law or put national security at risk. At the same time, greater power brings greater responsibility. Being a major technology supplier should mean having more responsibility, not facing fewer checks.

Washington must also understand that restrictions alone cannot stop China's progress in technology. Beijing has invested heavily in its own chip and semiconductor industries and AI abilities. Even when it becomes harder to get the most advanced American chips, Chinese companies keep looking for other options and often build their own.

There have already been reports that Chinese AI companies are trying to get access to data centers powered by Nvidia chips outside China. They are doing this because they fear Washington may make its rules even stricter.

This shows that tighter export rules can create new business opportunities for middlemen in other countries without necessarily achieving their goal.

The United States needs to work more closely with countries that host major data centers, especially in Asia. Governments must share information, improve checks on customers, and make sure cloud computing services do not become an easy way to get around export rules.

In the end, the Nvidia scandal is a warning that the AI race cannot be won simply by limiting what another country can buy. America must invest in its own technology, try to protect its supply chains, and make sure its companies understand the serious responsibilities they have.

Huang's departure may be the main story in the news for now, but the bigger problem will remain long after the scandal disappears from the headlines. If Washington wants to lead the AI race, it must understand that controlling the movement of computer chips is only a small part of the challenge. Controlling access to computing power in a connected world is much harder.

The views and opinions in this article belong only to the author. They do not necessarily represent the editorial views, values or position of Daily Sabah. The newspaper provides space for different opinions as part of its commitment to open and informed public discussion.