Some employers are recruiting workers they laid off for AI
More than half (52%) of workers in the US and UK have experienced or heard about companies bringing back workers they previously replaced with AI.
Companies that laid off workers to invest in AI may now be questioning those decisions.
More than half (52%) of workers in the US and UK who were surveyed by SHL, a company that studies workers and talent, have experienced or heard about someone who has experienced what is called “AI rebounding.” This happens when companies try to hire back workers they laid off while spending money on AI. They have realized that some jobs still need people to do them.
“Instead of investing in the people they already had, they chose to let them go,” Sujay Saha, an employee experience expert and founder and CEO of consulting firm Cortico-X, told HR Brew. “Now, what they are doing…[is] hiring back many people who have training in AI or the ability to learn it.”
What’s happening? This year, companies including Microsoft, Oracle, and Amazon have cut many jobs so they can spend more money on AI. Many companies have followed this approach in recent years as AI tools have become more common at work.
When companies look for a return on their investment, “replacing employees with AI is an easy win. On paper, it looks like you have improved productivity. ‘We’ve got rid of headcount. Aren’t we doing good?’” Lucy Beaumont, SHL’s global senior vice president of product, told HR Brew. “But if you don't think it through, you can make mistakes and then have to hire those people again. I hope people start thinking more carefully about these decisions and stop making that mistake.”
Even though the job market has been fairly quiet in recent months, the latest JOLTS data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics showed that more workers changed jobs in September. This may make laid-off workers feel more hopeful. They may also be less likely to rush back to their old employers or accept an offer because they feel they have no other choice.
The SHL survey suggests that many workers may want better conditions before returning. Eight percent said they would refuse to work for a company again after being replaced by AI. Among those who would consider returning, 51% said they would need a promise of higher pay, 42% wanted job security, and 40% wanted clear information about how AI would be used in their job.
“What that is saying is, ‘We don’t trust you anymore. You’ve broken our trust, so we may come back, but how can we start building that trust again? I want to understand: Is my job safe here, and exactly how will AI be used?’” Beaumont said.
How this affects HR. Beaumont said that HR leaders should think about the “bigger costs” of hiring workers back after laying them off.
“The costs include lower employee morale, less interest in the job, and lower productivity. People will leave as soon as they get the chance,” she said. “The impact is much bigger than what that report shows, because building trust is very hard. It is easy to break trust and very hard to build it again.”
Saha said that recruiters who are hiring former employees again should look for people who can adapt and are willing to learn and change as technology develops. Workers will need to build this ability, and recruiters will need to look for it, so companies can stay competitive.
“These are very challenging times, when many things are changing. Employees need to understand that they must prepare themselves and be ready for change,” he said. “It’s not about missing skills. It’s about being able to adapt and change.”
