AI for texts and cards? When using a chatbot for personal messages crosses a line

NBC Connecticut

Source published: Site published:

Original article

As more people use chatbots to write emails or take care of everyday tasks, an important question comes up: Is it wrong to use them to write personal messages?

By Albert Stumm | The Associated Press ••

NBC Universal, Inc.

Energy prices, interest rates and investment choices could affect the financial impact of the growth in data centers. An expert explains the possible money risks.

A purple box sat on a folding table in Alamo Square in San Francisco. It might have looked like a tissue box, but it held dozens of secrets.

Oliva Tai was nearby, watching people walk past and try to understand a sign that said, “Confession box: Everyone has an AI secret.”

People shared many kinds of secrets. Some said they let AI do too much of their work. Others said they used it to choose a place for a first date. Several people admitted using AI to write very personal messages: “I had AI write my breakup text.” “I had ChatGPT date my boyfriend. Every text.” “I used AI to write my girlfriend’s grandmother’s 80th birthday letter.”

One person wrote: “I used AI to win an argument. Lol, not proud, but I won.”

Tai is an artist who has set up this project more than a dozen times in the Bay Area, New York and Denver. She said calling it a “confession” suggested that people felt at least a little guilty about using AI. But they used it anyway.

More and more people are using chatbots to write emails and take care of everyday tasks. This raises some questions: Is it wrong to use AI to write personal messages? Is it OK to use it for a holiday card or birthday message? What about a love letter or wedding vows?

Some people use AI to write personal messages, even when they feel guilty

Danielle Hass studied how people feel about using AI to write personal messages as part of her Ph.D. research in consumer behavior. She used experiments in which people read and responded to made-up situations. She found that people who had used AI before felt just as guilty as people who had never used it.

“Everyone felt guilty,” said Hass, a professor at Kennesaw State University in Georgia. “The driver of this relationship was dishonesty, that people felt like they were manipulating.”

Scott Claessens, a senior researcher at the University of Bristol in the UK, said people may still judge AI users negatively even when they are open about using AI.

Claessens said his research suggests that people see those who use AI as lazier, less skilled and less trustworthy.

He pointed out that people already use other things to help with social tasks. For example, they may buy birthday cards with messages already written inside or use ready-made poems in love notes. But he said people dislike how little effort AI seems to require.

“What we really want in our social relationships is for people to put effort in, because it shows that as a signal that you’re invested in the relationship,” he said.

How to tell when using AI is not OK

Sarah Newman worked with Tai as the director of art and education at Harvard University’s metaLAB. She said AI is becoming popular so quickly that people will probably develop shared ideas about when it is OK to use it and when it is not.

She suggested paying attention to feelings of doubt. Imagine using AI to write your wedding vows. Would you feel comfortable telling your partner that you used it? If not, then don't use it.

“Personal messages don’t need to be perfect,” Newman said. “Part of what makes these messages authentic and endearing is that they are imperfect.”

Tai and Claessens said there may be good reasons to use AI in personal situations. For example, someone might use it to communicate better with a partner who speaks a different first language. People with learning disabilities, such as dyslexia, might also use it for help.

Hass believes people are quickly accepting that AI can help them work more efficiently in some jobs. But she said she is glad people still feel guilty about using it to write personal messages.

“Guilt’s purpose in this context is to show us our interpersonal wrongdoings,” Hass said. “It’s showing us, ‘hey, this is where you’re supposed to be human.’”

Copyright The Associated Press

Other sources for this story