Homeland Security Chief Blames AI for Outages on 'One Guy's' Word, Contradicting DOT
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin told Fox News this week that artificial intelligence might be behind a nationwide halt to air travel and several other recent technology failures. He admitted that this idea came from just one unnamed person he knows in the technology industry. His claim also goes against what the Transportation Department has said.
Host Sean Hannity asked Mullin whether people were right to suspect AI after the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) ordered all flights across the country to stop last Friday. The question also mentioned technology problems at JPMorgan, Microsoft and United Airlines. Mullin said he had asked someone he knew who worked in technology about the possible cause.
"I talked to one guy in the tech industry, he asked not to mention his name, it's not Elon," Mullin said, according to an account of the interview. "I asked, what could be causing these outages? He said I believe it's the SI, because these programs aren't designed to work as fast as SI is."
Mullin explained that he thought the problem could spread from one change to many others. "When they put in a program that's able to write codes and it goes in and self-fixes, as it starts to self-fix itself, it's like doing a change order on a house," he said. "When you change one thing on a house, everything else starts changing, that's a ripple effect." He added: "That kind of makes sense to me."
The secretary also told viewers that the country was probably not under a cyberattack. He said he was "98%" sure and told the public to "breathe." But he did not provide a technical review or intelligence findings to support his idea about AI.
These comments do not match the position of Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy. Over the weekend, Duffy blamed longtime defense contractor L3Harris for "incompetence" and said AI did not cause the nationwide flight stoppage. He focused on why the company was making network upgrades to air traffic control systems on a busy Friday afternoon.
The FAA had introduced an AI-assisted tool for planning flight routes just days before the stoppage. This timing had already led some people to wonder whether the tool had caused problems with older network equipment. But no official investigation has confirmed a connection.
Mullin's use of the abbreviation "SI," a way of referring to AI linked with President Donald Trump, drew criticism. So did his decision to rely on just one unnamed person for his explanation.
"How about we get some facts before just saying stuff?" Representative Ted Lieu, a Democrat from California, wrote in response. "Maybe outages are caused by AI (no normal person calls it SI). Maybe they're caused by non-AI software bugs. Maybe it's old equipment."
Data analyst Nate Silver questioned how the administration was communicating with the public. He said clearer language would be more helpful than the short form the administration prefers to use.
The incident points to a bigger problem: the federal government may not have enough ability to find out why failures happen in digital systems that depend on one another. Engineers warned about these risks long before today's growth in AI. Old equipment and software systems that are closely connected can allow one small problem to cause much larger failures. This happened during the 2003 blackout, when a software problem in Ohio helped cause power outages across New York City and much of the Northeast.
AI creates another source of uncertainty. Even the people who develop AI say they cannot fully predict how large AI models will behave when used in important systems. Because of this, some experts who closely follow the technology expect problems to happen more often and become harder to explain.
For financial markets, the main question now is whether officials can give a trustworthy technical explanation for last week's flight stoppage, which disrupted travel for days. Airlines had to pay for canceled flights and rebooking. Investors in cloud computing and business software companies are also facing new questions about how quickly AI tools are being put into everyday use.
A clear finding about what happened would matter to insurance companies, regulators and the contractors responsible for maintaining air traffic networks. So far, the public has heard one cabinet secretary repeat a private conversation and another cabinet secretary blame a company. No detailed investigation report has been released.
Mullin said he planned to ask more people for their views. "We just have a lot of technologists thrown at us and our world runs on technology now," he said. "We used to have backup systems. And the backup systems are overwhelmed by the new systems now."
