OpenAI’s Religion Report But No Breakdown for Pagan Requests
News
By Manny Tejeda y Moreno |
SAN FRANCISCO — OpenAI estimates that people around the world send ChatGPT more than 70 million requests mainly about religion every week. Its October report, Faith, Community & AI, does not explain how questions about Paganism and Witchcraft were counted.
In April 2023, we asked three chatbots a simple question: “What do you think about Witchcraft?” ChatGPT described different beliefs and practices, including modern Witchcraft as a spiritual path. Google’s Bard gave a positive description. Microsoft’s Bing Chat began by connecting Witchcraft with evil purposes. The same question produced three very different descriptions of a practice that many of our readers know well.
In June, The Wild Hunt reported on a study that asked popular AI chatbots 150 questions about grief, relationships, forgiveness, and other difficult situations where religion might affect someone's answer. The questions did not directly ask for a religious point of view, and the chatbots often did not mention religion. The researchers checked whether religion appeared in the answers at all. They did not check whether the answers correctly represented Pagan or other specific religious traditions, or whether adding a religious point of view made the advice better.
MJT Image
OpenAI now estimates that people around the world send ChatGPT more than 70 million requests mainly about religion every week. Its October 2026 report, Faith, Community & AI, describes how people use the chatbot to study sacred writings, get ready for religious events, and think about beliefs and the meaning of life. But the report does not mention Paganism or Witchcraft by name. This raises a question that we could not have asked in quite the same way in 2023: When people discuss their Pagan religious lives with ChatGPT, how does OpenAI identify and count those conversations?
OpenAI says its research protects people's privacy, but it gives very few details about how it chose or sorted the requests it studied. It does not provide separate numbers for modern Pagan religions. Because of this, the published information cannot tell us what share of religion-related requests were about modern Paganism. For example, someone might ask how to light a candle for a deity. Without more context, this could look like a question about folklore or a request for help with creative writing. But the person asking might really be asking about worship. The report does not explain how OpenAI sorted questions like this or how Pagan users felt about the answers.
OpenAI studied requests from August 24 through September 20, 2026. It found that studying religious texts made up about 22 million requests each week. About 16 million requests each week were about religious practices and holidays. Another 16 million were about beliefs, life's meaning, and spiritual advice. These numbers count requests, not people. For example, someone who spends an afternoon asking questions about one passage might create several requests. The report does not say how many people use ChatGPT for religious reasons, how often they come back, or what they do with its answers.
In a different study covering September 2025 through September 2026, requests about Islam made up about 45 percent of all religion-related requests. Christianity came next at 34 percent, followed by Hinduism at 4 percent, Judaism at 2 percent, and Buddhism at 1 percent. OpenAI says these five religions together made up about 85 percent of the requests it studied. It also noticed changes in requests around religious events, including Ramadan, Eid al-Adha, Easter, and Passover. These numbers show what people talked about, not necessarily what religion they follow. For example, a question about fasting during Ramadan could come from a Muslim getting ready to observe the fast or from a coworker who wants to understand it.
OpenAI says its research protects people's privacy, but it gives readers little information about how it selected and sorted the requests. It does not provide separate numbers for Pagan, Witchcraft, Heathen, or African diasporic traditions. It also does not explain where questions about these traditions might appear in its results. A question about lighting a candle for a deity might look like a question about folklore or creative writing when read without context. But the person asking might be asking about worship. The report does not give readers enough information to know how OpenAI handled this difference.
One of the report's most interesting examples comes from Sandhya Simhan, a Hindu educator in California. She asked ChatGPT for advice about a family problem. At first, the chatbot focused on setting personal limits. It did not give enough importance to family duties and respect for older relatives, which mattered to her. Simhan then asked ChatGPT to interview her about her beliefs and the teachers she followed. She saved this information so it could be used in future conversations. She knew enough to notice that the first answer did not fit her beliefs. Someone who is new to a religion might believe an equally confident answer without realizing that something is wrong.
Other people described in the report say they use ChatGPT as a starting point for learning. Rabbi Andrew Bloom of Fort Worth uses a customized study guide to find Jewish commentary, then checks the original writings. The Rev. Dr. Adolphus Lacey, a Baptist pastor in Brooklyn, asks the chatbot where a sermon might be difficult for someone who is new to faith. Harrison Kim, a Protestant in Seoul who uses ChatGPT to study the Bible, worries about what happens when people share their problems only with a chatbot. Their friends or pastors might never find out that they need help.
OpenAI's report gives few details about how it sorted requests. It does not make clear whether questions about modern Pagan religions were counted as religious questions or, if they were, how they were grouped. Because of this, the published numbers cannot tell us what share of religion-related requests were about modern Paganism or how Pagan people felt about the chatbot's answers.
Based on comments on The Wild Hunt articles and statements from many Pagan leaders, there is widespread doubt about using AI for religious or spiritual experiences beyond simple explanations of facts. The Covenant of the Goddess¹ published a statement about using AI in sacred practices. It said that it “remains unconvinced that artificial intelligence can participate in or substitute for the lived spiritual experiences through which we encounter the sacred, deepen intuition, build relationships, and draw insight from the wellsprings of spirit, mind, and soul.”
OpenAI's new report gives us an idea of how often people discuss religion with ChatGPT. But for religious communities that the report does not mention, important questions remain. We still do not know how the system understands their religious lives, especially when they belong to smaller religious groups.
1. Disclosure: Tejeda y Moreno is the editor-in-chief of The Wild Hunt. His comments on behalf of the Covenant do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of TWH and are reviewed by an independent editor.↩
