Why Youth Are Turning to AI for Mental Health Advice - Technology Org

Technology Org

Source published: Site published:

Original article · فارسی

Posted Today

A Rutgers mental health expert explains the possible benefits and risks of young adults using AI chatbots for advice.

Machine learning, mental health - artistic impression. Image credit: Alius Noreika / AI

Machine learning and mental health – artistic impression. Image credit: Alius Noreika / AI

According to a survey by the nonpartisan research group RAND, about 8.2 million people, or nearly 1 in 5 U.S. teenagers and young adults ages 12 to 21, use artificial intelligence (AI) to find mental health information.

Chatbots such as ChatGPT and Gemini are becoming more common sources of emotional support and mental health advice. But a Rutgers mental health expert and other healthcare professionals are concerned. These computer programs may not be able to handle mental health conditions properly and could put users at risk.

Hannah Simon is a child and adolescent psychiatrist and medical director of the Brandt Behavioral Health Treatment Center and Retreat at Rutgers. The center provides mental health care based on scientific evidence, as well as outpatient services, for young people and young adults in New Jersey. Simon talks about the growing use of chatbots for mental health advice and how people can use them safely as learning tools.

Why are young adults turning to AI to explore mental health questions?
Young adults have grown up using technology to manage almost every part of their lives. So, using AI to ask questions about mental health is a natural next step in the way they already look for information.

AI also offers things that traditional mental health services cannot always provide: instant access at any time of day or night, low-cost or free information, and privacy. Young people who feel uncomfortable talking to their parents or healthcare professionals may find AI a private place where they can ask questions without feeling judged.

There are also major problems with getting mental health care in the United States. There are not enough mental health professionals, especially child and adolescent psychiatrists. This means people may have to wait a long time for appointments. Insurance does not always cover enough of the cost, so patients may have to pay large amounts themselves. For many young people, getting psychiatric care is simply difficult or too expensive. AI gives them a quick way to find information, but it cannot take the place of an expert's assessment or treatment.

What are the possible benefits of using AI to learn about mental health?
AI chatbots can make mental health information easier to find. Young people can learn about common symptoms, understand medical terms, explore ways to cope with difficult feelings and recognize when they may need help from a professional.

What are the risks of using AI for mental health questions?
My biggest concern is that AI can give wrong or misleading information while sounding very sure and convincing. A young person might describe a few symptoms, such as feeling anxious, having worried thoughts or having trouble sleeping. The chatbot might then suggest a specific mental health condition, such as an anxiety disorder. But AI does not have the medical knowledge and judgment needed to make a diagnosis.

Many mental health conditions have similar symptoms. Telling them apart requires a careful and complete assessment that looks at a person's surroundings and life, as well as possible medical problems.

Chatbots also tend to agree with users and make them feel understood. Giving too much reassurance can make negative mental health symptoms stronger. In some cases, this can work against treatment. For example, when treating obsessive-compulsive disorder, we often help patients learn to live with uncertainty instead of always looking for reassurance. AI may do the opposite. It can give endless reassurance that makes someone feel better for a short time but can strengthen the repeated cycle of anxiety and compulsive behavior.

Does AI create barriers or bridges to getting mental health care from people?
It can do both. Young people may become too dependent on their personal AI chatbot for emotional support. This could take time and attention away from important relationships with other people and from learning how to deal with difficult feelings on their own.

But AI can also help young people connect with other people. It can provide a comfortable, low-pressure way to learn about their experiences and find the words to explain their feelings to friends, family members and healthcare professionals.

What are some good ways to use AI to learn about mental health?
I often tell patients to use AI as a learning tool, not as a medical expert. AI can help people explore information about mental health conditions, learn about treatment choices and ways to cope, and recognize unhealthy patterns in their thoughts or behavior.

However, I would not use AI to diagnose yourself, make decisions about medication or deal with a mental health emergency. Check important information with more reliable sources, such as the National Institute of Mental Health, the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry or a qualified healthcare professional.

Young people should also be careful about sharing private information because conversations with AI may not be fully protected.

They should watch out for becoming too dependent on AI and pay attention to how using it makes them feel. If chatting with a bot makes their anxiety worse, strengthens unhealthy habits or takes up so much time that they spend less time with friends, they should think again about how they use the technology.

What advice do you have for parents of young adults?
Parents should ask questions with interest and without judging. They can talk with their children about how they use AI, what they are learning and whether they find it helpful.

In my experience as a doctor, today's teenagers and young adults are often more willing to talk about mental health than people from earlier generations. However, fear of how their parents might react can still stop them from getting care. I often hear young patients say they worry that their parents do not believe in therapy or think that needing treatment means something is seriously wrong with them. Others worry that treatment will cost their families too much money. AI can give young people a way to explore these issues without having to start those difficult conversations right away.

Importantly, a teenager using AI for mental health advice is not always a reason to worry. It may be an early sign that they have noticed they are struggling emotionally and are looking for help. Parents can use this as a chance to talk about mental health and help their child find the right support.

However, parents should watch for signs that AI use is becoming unhealthy. This is especially important if it affects sleep, schoolwork, time with friends or other activities, or causes the young person to worry too much about possible mental health diagnoses.

In the end, I encourage parents to work with their children when talking about AI, rather than punish them for using it. The goal is not necessarily to stop them from using AI. It is to understand what they get from it and make sure they feel comfortable asking their parents for help when they need it.

Source: Rutgers University